Quantcast The Daily Texan
ADVERTISEMENT

An Olympic mistake

By Jillian Sheridan
  • Print
  • Email
  • Page 1 of 1
I love the Olympics. I have watched them for as long as I can remember, and I have been counting down the days until next year's event in Bejing - at least until I walked into a demonstration in front of the UT Tower for the Human Rights Torch Relay.

The Human Rights Torch Relay is a movement encouraging countries to boycott the 2008 Olympics. They aim to remind the world of the values of the Olympics - freedom, peace and equality - which they say China does not uphold. The relayers handed out pamphlets stating, "The Olympics and crimes against humanity cannot co-exist in China." The group claims that the Chinese government is not only imprisoning citizens for religious activities and political opposition, but it is executing those citizens and selling their organs.

At first I was skeptical. Many organizations demonstrate on the steps of the tower, and quite a few of them are completely insane. I asked my friend who moved from China eight years ago if she thought there was any truth to these claims, and she told me they were ridiculous. She was adamant that there is nothing going on in China like the protesters were depicting. I wondered if she had just been brainwashed by the lies of the Chinese government.

But then I had a thought: Perhaps these are lies propagated by my own government to get Americans to fear China and to fear communism and thus become more loyal citizens. Unfortunately, many of us cannot travel the world and investigate issues for ourselves. We have to trust other sources of information, and it is difficult to determine the truth considering all the biases and lies that come through interest groups, governments and the media.

The claims of the Human Rights Torch Relay, however, are accepted nearly everywhere. The organization is international and is supported by citizens around the world. In fact, 10,000 Chinese citizens signed a petition calling for human rights in their country before the Olympics. David Matas, an international human rights lawyer, and David Kilgour, the former Canadian Secretary of State for Asia-Pacific, published a report in February entitled "Bloody Harvest," which claims that Falun Gong practitioners are being illegally executed for their religious beliefs so that the Chinese government can sell their organs. Falun Gong is a spirituality-based movement that was introduced to China in 1992, and its practitioners have been prosecuted by the government since 1999.

Some critics liken the movement to a cult, and Beijing sees it as a threat to national security. Matas and Kilgour's report cites 41,500 unexplained organ transplants from 2000 to 2005 that didn't come from executed prisoners, the brain-dead nor family donors. The U.N. has alleged the same thing against the Chinese government, but it's difficult to ensure that evidence on either side is legitimate. Human rights groups in China have limited access to research.

In its quest to host the 2008 Olympics, the Chinese government vowed to improve human rights in their country. But according to Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch, serious violations of human rights are continuing in China. In fact, some of these violations are a part of China's preparation for the Olympic games, such as imprisonment of citizens who have sent letters to the International Olympic Committee calling for improvements in China's human rights, forcible illegal evictions of thousands of Beijing residents and suppression of groups that the government fears will embarrass the nation during the games, such as Falun Gong practitioners.

In the face of condemning research and global agreement, it is hard to deny that China is violating the rights of many of its citizens. Now the question is: What does that mean for the Olympics? According to the fundamental principles in the Olympic Charter, "Olympism seeks to create a way of life based on the joy found in effort, the educational value of good example and respect for universal fundamental ethical principles."

Clearly, China is not living up to that principle. So should we boycott the 2008 Olympic games? Many American athletes have trained for their entire lives to compete at these games, and this is their one shot at amateur glory. However, this could be our one shot to convince China to stop torturing and attacking its own citizens. We need to intensify our demands for improved human rights for the citizens of China. We should hold the Chinese government to its promise to the world. If it continues to ignore the spirit of the Olympics, we need to take a stand by boycotting these games - even if that means I won't get to enjoy the Olympics next year.

Sheridan is a Plan II and political communications sophomore.
Page 1 of 1

Article Tools

The Texan strives to present all information fairly, accurately and completely.
If we have made an error, let us know about it here, or email managingeditor@dailytexanonline.com.

Voice your opinion!

Let your voice be heard. Fill out your comments below.
Be sure to include your name, major, and classification. Submissions without this information are subject to deletion.
By clicking Post, you give The Daily Texan the right to publish your comments in any form, including online and in print in The Firing Line. Please limit your comments to 300 words. The Daily Texan reserves the right to edit all comments for brevity, clarity and liability.
You may also send Firing Lines to the editor at firingline@dailytexanonline.com

Viewing Comments 1 - 10 of 16

Jinhu Guo

posted 11/18/07 @ 12:36 PM CST

This article sucks and it really can't cover the fact that the author is narrow and ignortant, though I didn't intent to claim this. I even don't bother to talk with this author. (Continued…)

Vivian Young

posted 11/18/07 @ 1:49 PM CST

After read through this article, I have a strong feeling that the author is one escaped out of a mental hospital, where she had been confined for half a centenary. (Continued…)

Tony Hu

posted 11/18/07 @ 3:23 PM CST

We chinese people are making our best effort to prepare the Olympic event. Your article is really hurting our feeling. Why not study more about a country before you want to comment on it?!

Lucia

posted 11/18/07 @ 9:51 PM CST

The article is a complete nonsense, and the author looks like a naive child whose mind has been easily twisted.

"In fact, 10,000 Chinese citizens signed a petition calling for human rights in their country before the Olympics. (Continued…)

ok123456

posted 11/19/07 @ 4:46 PM CST

I don't think the author understand China, I wonder who is the God in your heart.
I request you provide the legal facts for what you told or you take your words back and say sorry to China. (Continued…)

James Sun

posted 11/20/07 @ 7:47 AM CST

I seriously doubt if the author had ever been to China, and if she ever know who are those Falun Gong practitioners.....

sean

posted 11/24/07 @ 10:05 PM CST

i don't wanna criticize a naive child anymore,
but i would like to interpellate the related editors of daily texan, how can you let such an ignorant and ex parte paper published?
There is no perfect people nor country in the world, as we can discuss lots of frightfulnesses in the US, either past or today. (Continued…)

Court Pearman

posted 12/03/07 @ 7:37 PM CST

Thank you for bringing this to the attention of your readers. As you can see from the hostile comments, Chinese feel strong about the Olympics. Many Chinese culture student organizations are actually funded by the Chinese Embassies and Consulates. (Continued…)

(1 reply)   Details   Reply to this comment

cori xiong

posted 12/18/07 @ 2:14 AM CST

the americans have a really stupid but good weapon at accusing other countries: human rights. the americans are really good at convincing their people into believing that countries like china, north korea, iraq, countries in the middle east are all evil and they do stuff like eating people, collecting people's organs, oh thats some pretty good brainwashing skills too right there. (Continued…)

Look here you Kung Fu Fighters wanna be King Kong, rice eaters

posted 12/19/07 @ 2:58 PM CST

America, Love it or Leave it! How dare you cat eating midgets, who can't even write good English, critize your hosts. Why don't you look at your Chinese torturing country for what it is?

We know that it is the Chinese government that is funding the oppositon in Iraq and Afganistan. (Continued…)

Post a Comment

  • NOTE: Email address will not be published

Type your comment below (html not allowed)

  I understand posting spam or other comments that are unrelated to this article will cause my comment to be flagged for deletion and possibly cause my IP address to be permanently banned from this server.

Advertisement

ADVERTISEMENTS


Moroccan Furniture
Humana Health Insurance
Prom Dresses 2009
Prom Dresses
Dresses Dresses
Designer Swimwear

Concert Tickets
Texas Longhorns Tickets
Prom Dresses 2009
Generate traffic! Advertise on dailytexanonline.com


Copyright (c) 2008 The Daily Texan and Texas Student Media. All Rights Reserved.
Advertising Rates | Around Campus | Contact Us | Submit a Firing Line | Submit Around Campus
Buy Photos |
Advertising Supplements | Super Coupons | Texas Student Media