College Media Network - Search the largest news resource for college students by college students

The trouble with affording Austin

By Ashley Shew

Daily Texan Columnist

Print this article

Published: Thursday, November 5, 2009

Updated: Thursday, November 5, 2009

Dear Austin: I give up.

You have bested me at every attempt to be frugal. I now have $100 and 87 Bevo Bucks left to my name. What do I have to show for the money I’ve forked over to you? Peanut butter and jelly on wheat bread and several parking garage receipts.

Austin, I know your proud citizens will jump at the chance to defend you as an economical place to live. After all, even The Daily Texan reports that you rank 56th out 77 U.S. cities in highest occupational wages. The Austin Chamber of Commerce’s Web site assures me that living in Texas is still cheaper than living in another state and that living in Austin is cheaper than living Houston.

But I’m not from Houston or another state. I moved here from one of the numerous tiny, no-name rural towns in northeast Texas. I am accustomed to a different definition of “cheap.”

Maybe it’s not you; maybe it’s me. After all, in a recent discussion in my anthropology class, I revealed that I have never been inside an Ikea and confessed that my experience on the acquisition of inexpensive home furnishings consisted of cruising the affluent Highland Park district of Dallas on trash day. My admission was met with laughter from my city-dwelling classmates. Apparently, I need a course in urban economics.

But aside from my obvious unfamiliarity with city life, Austin, you still manage to wreak havoc on my budget. I don’t appreciate incurring some fee or another every time I turn around. Stubb’s Bar-B-Q lured me out Friday night for the screening of the greatest comedy of all time, “The Big Lebowski.” This was easy because the $20 tickets advertised were not out of my price range for a worthy distraction from midterms. But alas, I was met with a $12 “convenience” charge for each of my two tickets. Effectively, I paid $60 to sit outside in the cold to watch a movie I’ve seen before. This was on top of the parking fee I paid a wild-eyed, twitchy attendant to park my car in 6 feet of mud and broken asphalt. My dismay at being forced into the poorhouse couldn’t even be lifted by two hours of Jeff Bridges in a bathrobe.

Parking here is the bane of my existence. Basically, anywhere you go, you must rent a space for a sizeable chunk of change. Of course, I realize this can be alleviated by taking the bus for free, but my need to arrive at appointments across town punctually rather than in the next century often makes driving a better alternative. At least, it seems that way until I get the bill.

And while CityData assures me that your apartments cost well below the national average, I can’t contain my sticker shock. Many an apartment locator representative has fanned me back from unconsciousness once I hear that 520 square feet of space costs $700 a month if I don’t wish to be robbed or live in a dumpster. One of my professors explained that while you still have the attitude of an inexpensive place to live, dear Austin, Dell’s settling in the city drove up the cost of living for your citizens. This may be a natural economic effect, but it does make it very difficult for a newcomer like me to afford a place to sleep.

I’m not mad at you, Austin; I’m just frustrated. I feel like, when it comes to money, we just aren’t communicating. You think that Wal-Mart is the epitome of frugal, and I happen to be acquainted with flea markets. You think living on the interstate is cheaper, and I’m not even really used to living on a paved road.

Austin, it seems like you have champagne tastes while I only have a

beer pocketbook.

Shew is a psychology junior.

 

Comments

22 comments
tylenol
Mon Nov 9 2009 22:13
The campuses should be closed to traffic, make it a bike, moped, pedestrian area that way there is less congestion.
What a headache.
Claire
Mon Nov 9 2009 14:22
To the columnist:
Seriously, stop using realtors and apartment locators. Stop now. Never go back. You can get a fair-sized studio in Austin, near campus for under $550 a month, and they probably know about these places, and won't show them to you because they get a proportional commission off of their rentals. If they can con you into dropping $800/month on an apartment, they'll do it in a heartbeat. It's worth the time and effort to dump the locating service and scour craigslist, put out feelers with your friends, or drive around the neighborhood you want to live in looking for rental signs. That's how I found my last place, and it's adorable and affordable.
The Cowardly Liberal
Mon Nov 9 2009 09:33
Tempest in a teapot, anyone?
mktiv
Fri Nov 6 2009 16:49
there's no reason to "take it down a notch". if a person is a junior at a respected school like ut and has the will to publish her opinions on the opinion page of a respected university daily newspaper then she should expect and want her opinions to be debated. isn't that what we have opinion pages of newpapers for?! if she wanted to be patted on the head and given a lolly pop she could go to story time at book people or something. you are being patronizing by saying people shouldn't air their strong opinions. i think the posters here have replied with well-thought out advice based on the premise of the article- saving money. i and others pointed out some major flaws in the logic of a person who wants to save money while insisting that she drive all over central austin and to downtown. the writer touched upon this in her article and we're right on target to comment that there are other ways to get around than by personal automobile. no one said she should give up her car or something, but we're trying to offer further advice since she is sooo troubled by the inconvenience of her perceived travel choices. austin has a good bus system and walkable/bikable areas (not everywhere but most areas around UT and in downtown). hopefully the writer has enjoyed the lively discussion and we've all walked away with new ideas about how to save money.
David
Fri Nov 6 2009 16:11
I have never before agreed with Cowardly Liberal, but I am today. People should take it down a notch. I thought this article was pretty good.
Your name
Thu Nov 5 2009 19:16
Too true. The comment section of an editorial column shouldn't actually be used to discuss the article, that would be silly.
Diveller
Thu Nov 5 2009 19:12
I think he meant acrostic, or maybe anacrusistic or Anacreontic. It's hard to tell with these mys-spellers.
ftagn
The Cowardly Liberal
Thu Nov 5 2009 16:09
Sam, did you mean anarchistic? Because an anachronism has to do with a conflict in chronology, like you might find in a Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur's Court.

Folks, don't let the joking tone fool you. This is tough minded, hard hitting journalism that is intended to grab you by the lapels and give you a good shaking. And that demands a good sound thrashing in return!

sam i am
Thu Nov 5 2009 15:53
folks please don't comment on the cowardly liberal's rants. he's obviously immature and is just really going for a light anacronistic affect. don't take him seriously. he doesn't really have an opinion that he'd like to see debated or taken literally. he's just having fun.
The Cowardly Liberal
Thu Nov 5 2009 15:39
Oh, pardon me for being patronizing. Perish the thought. Tar and feather her and send her back to Mayberry RFD.
Your name
Thu Nov 5 2009 15:25
If it is a light human interest piece it has no business being on the Editorial Page of one of the Premier Student Newspapers in the country. The Daily Texan's editorial standards have been slipping for years, but this sort of class project writing has no place in a professional newspaper, which is what the daily Texan pretends to be.
DJL
Thu Nov 5 2009 15:06
If it is a humor column it should be in the travesty. Since it is in the opinion section of the texan it can be held to the same standard as anything else. The fact that is has a light-hearted tone does not mean the author is not trying to make legitimate points, and if she is, then those points are fair-game for criticism.

Also, it is pretty patronizing to imply author's intent. I'm sure the columnist would much rather readers debate the validity of her arguments than simply dismiss the entire piece as something that shouldn't be taken seriously.

Wish I Could Have Stayed
Thu Nov 5 2009 14:08
Love it Ashley! While I miss Austin terribly, I haven't the financial means to be able to afford the kind of life that I enjoy in North Carolina. Austin will always be my lottery prize, alas one must be willing to fork it over in order to win the jackpot.
The Cowardly Liberal
Thu Nov 5 2009 14:03
Folks, it's a humor column, 'mkay? The writer is going for a light, comic effect while detailing the economic pitfalls common to college students living in Austin. Sure, maybe she could get around on a bike. That's what I do. But I'm not going to treat her column like some kind of pinata and try and bash it full of holes. Why not? Because this is a light, human interest piece, not a treatise on free market economics. Now, boil up some ramen and get back to your thriftier-than-thou existences.
mktiv
Thu Nov 5 2009 13:34
I came from small-town Texas to the "big" city of Austin as well, a few years ago, to attend UT. In my town to me as a high schooler having a car and driving it everywhere meant freedom and mobility. I didn't think twice about bringing it with me to school. That is until I realized it would cost me $500+ a semester to park it on campus! I didn't bring it with me and I quickly realized just as having a car in small town Texas did give me a sense of mobility and freedom, having a car while attending school and driving it to and from class everyday would be the exact opposite of freedom. Like someone else said, you've become a slave to your own "stuff"- owned by your possessions. If you want to cut back on expenses stop insisting on driving your car everywhere you go. Have a car, but commute to school by bus or bike. It's better for you, the environment and your wallet.
Your name
Thu Nov 5 2009 12:44
Dear Column: Try harder.

You also grew up in a small town in northeast Texas, not Calcutta. Quit creating some false dichotomy between big-spending, Cadillac-drivin city slickers and hard-workin, penny-pinchin country folk because, for one, you aren't really very thrifty. You could have forgone the luxuries of guaranteed seating and transportation by taking the E-bus to Stubbs, and buying tickets at the door (I assume the convenience charge was for an an online purchase). For that matter, you could have just rented the movie from Vulcan Video for 3 bucks.

Same goes with parking. It is not difficult to learn what time buses will arrive at certain stops and to plan your schedule accordingly. Obviously driving is easier, and you pay for that convenience with parking fees and such.

You also pay for the convenience and safety of living close to campus. Riverside isn't South Central L.A., it is just not as secure or accessible as West or North Campus, which is why it is cheaper.

That said, Realtors lie, you can get 520 sq feet for less than 7 bills, the realtor just won't get as big of a commission.

Living frugally requires sacrifice. Obviously it is easier cheaper to live in a town than a city, but thats because there are so many benefits of living in a city. You don't get to talk up your flea-market, beer drinkin'*, furniture scavenging, unpaved road** lifestyle when there is a cheaper, albeit less convenient, alternative for every example.

Column: It isn't that Austin is too expensive, you just want to enjoy the benefits of living in a city without paying for them.

*Column: If you can't find cheap drink specials in Austin you just aren't trying hard enough
**Column: unpaved roads vs. interstate highways? What does that even mean? I don't really think highways are considered an urban extravagance.

Tweetie
Thu Nov 5 2009 12:29
When we were in Cali, everyone complained about how expensive it was to live there. And it was - if you wanted to live by the ocean. It's the same here in Austin. Rent is as high as it is in Dallas - if you want to live in Central Austin. My husband and I found a great deal over on Mopac and 290, which is in a beautiful area and not in the suburbs of Austin (thank goodness). Myself and most of my friends were laid off, and we still manage to find cheap things to do - you just have to search.
Crockett Cougar
Thu Nov 5 2009 11:58
Shew:
It's clear you aren't from around here. It is cheaper to live in Houston and the occupational wages are generally higher. Your so-called city dwelling classmates are apparently from a higher economic class than you are, most Austinites would get arrested for dumpster diving in Highland Park. I lived in Austin for years and rarely had any trouble finding parking or getting to appointments by riding the bus until I moved to Cedar Park, which isn't in the CapMetro District. If you're from a small town, you should be able to find comparable living quarters in Austin for less than $700 a month by getting a roommate or three. There are at least two flea markets in Austin, one of which is on the bus route. Don't criticize the city because of your own spend thrift habits.
yawnmoth
Thu Nov 5 2009 11:35
If you can't use buses to get to appointments on time then you're not using them correctly. Do you not look at schedules before going out to the bus stop?

What about for TV programs? Do you not look at schedules before turning on the TV or did your oh-so-isolated farmhouse have a time shifting DVR?

And if you want to visit affluent neighborhoods on trash day to get new furniture you're still free to do that. That there's an IKEA in north Round Rock doesn't mean you're somehow obligated to use it.

Also, if you're willing to pay $40.00 for 2x tickets for The Big Lebowski, why not save $25.00 and buy the DVD, instead?

Austin may not be as cheap as some rural town but it doesn't have to be as expensive as you're making it, either.

Gx
Thu Nov 5 2009 11:11
There are plenty of inexpensive and often free things to do in Austin, you just got to look around a bit. Austin is not and never has been a cheap city to live in however.






log out